Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: Which is best suited to your needs?

Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: Which is best suited to your needs?
Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y.

Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: which of these 2 electric SUVs is best suited to your needs and budget? Complexe VW 440, your Volkswagen dealership in Laval, tells you more about this Volkswagen SUV along with all that it has to offer compared to the 2023 Tesla Model Y!

Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: The Different Trim Levels  

The Volkswagen iD.4 is offered in 3 trim levels:

  • 4 Pro 
  • 4 Pro AWD 

As for the Tesla Model Y, the following trims are offered:

  • Model Y (RWD) 
  • Model Y Long Range (AWD) 
  • Model Y Performance (AWD) 
Front 3/4 view of the 2023 Volkswagen iD.4 driving on a road.

2023 Volkswagen iD.4

Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: Interior and Exterior Design

The 2023 Volkswagen ID.4’s bold and athletic lines, along with the numerous available body colors, make it truly irresistible. The stylized fascia, the 19- inch or 20- inch wheels, the LED headlights and taillights along with the panoramic glass sunroof also add to the overall charm.

Inside, you will find a redesigned central console, along with ambient lighting with a choice of 30- colors. Amenities are numerous and include climate control over 3- zones and heated front and rear seats, depending on selected trim and options.

As for the Model Y, despite a very successful design, it is more bland, and simply not as stunning as the ID.4 design. Moreover, you will only have a selection of 5 available body colors, compared to 13 for the Volkswagen, which also offers 3 different 2-tone body color options. It can be equipped with 19- to 21- inch wheels, depending on selected model.

The interior is minimalist and streamlined, and standard offered in black; you can also choose a white interior, as an added option.

Front interior of the 2023 Volkswagen ID.4 including the dashboard.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4

Electric SUVs: Dimensions

The Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y dimensions are relatively close; the Model Y however, is slightly more imposing:

  Volkswagen iD.4 Tesla Model Y
Length 4,584 mm 4,750 mm
Width 1,852 mm 2,129 mm
Height 1,639 mm 1,624 mm
Wheelbase 2,765 mm 2,890 mm
Seating 5 5 or 7

iD.4 vs Model Y: Specs

The 2023 iD.4 specs sheet, just like the Model Y, gives us loads of interesting information in terms of range, versatility and performance.

Front 3/4 view of the gray 2023 Volkswagen ID.4 driving on a road.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4

Range and Power

When it comes to electric range for the iD.4, it can reach between 410 and 433 kilometers on a single charge, depending on selected trim. Moreover, the entry-level trim is equipped with a 201 horsepower electric motor with a 62 kWh battery; as for the intermediate trim, it also offers 201 horsepower, but it is equipped with an 82 kWh battery. This is the same battery found on the superior trim, which offers 295 horsepower.

While you are traveling, you can expect to be able to recover from 10 % to 80 % charge in around 30 minutes. This also translates into adding around 100 km of range with a 10 minute charging time.

As for the Model Y, it will give you a range between 394 and 531 km, depending on selected trim, and between 384 and 456 horsepower. It is also equipped with a 75 kWh battery.

Towing Capacity and Cargo Space

The Tesla Model Y offers an amount of cargo space that can reach up to 2,158 liters, once rear seats are folded. It can also tow up to 3,527 lbs (1,600 kg).

As for the ID.4 electric, it can tow up to 2,700 pounds with the all-wheel drive system, and will provide you with anywhere between 858 and 1,818 liters of cargo space.

Technologies 

The Volkswagen iD.4 also stands out from the Tesla Model Y when it comes to added technologies; and although the later offers a 15- inch touch screen –compared to 12- inches for the iD.4- it does not offer Apple CarPlay/Android Auto compatibility, contrary to the Volkswagen Canada SUV, for which this is included as standard offerd equipment.

Among the technologies you will find aboard the iD.4, you will have:

  • A navigation system;
  • Keyless entry with push button start;
  • Adaptive cruise control;
  • Emergency assistance and lane keep assist;
  • Front emergency braking with pedestrian and cyclist detection;
  • Automatic control and detection of traffic lights;
  • Road sign display;
  • Front and rear park assist;
  • And much more, depending on selected trim.
2023 Volkswagen ID.4 roadside assistance display panel.

Take note that on the Tesla Model Y, almost all commands go through the touch screen; so expect to need some time to adapt, in order to really understand how it works and to get used to the absence of a dashboard, especially given that all of the info related to speed and kilometers are displayed on the 15- inch screen to the right of the driver.

Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: Prices 

The 3 trim levels of the iD.4 are offered at the following MSRP:

  • 4: $ 49,160
  • 4 Pro: $ 53,160
  • 4 Pro AWD: $ 58,160

As for the Model Y, prices are as follows:

  • Model Y (RWD): $ 59,990
  • Model Y Long Range (AWD): $ 69,990
  • Model Y Performance (AWD): $ 76,290

As you can see, the price difference between these two SUVs is quite significant, and the iD.4 is definitely more affordable. 

Conclusion

In short, if the most important for you –while shopping for an electric SUV- is an affordable price, then the choice is easy: the Volkswagen iD.4 definitely has the advantage, while also offering loads of added technologies. The Model Y, however, offers superior performance on some trims along with a slightly higher range.

To find out more about our Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y comparison, about our current Volkswagen special offers in Laval or to get more information regarding our Volkswagen financing plans, come and visit us at Complexe VW 440 in Laval, close to Terrebonne, Montreal North and the North Shore of Montreal!

Volkswagen iD.4 vs Tesla Model Y: summary comparison table

  Volkswagen iD.4 Tesla Model Y
Price Range $ 49,160 - $ 58,160 $ 59,990 - $ 76,290
Power 201—295 horsepower 384—456 horsepower
Range 410—433 kilometers 394—531 kilometers
Towing Capacity 2,700 pounds 3,527 pounds
Cargo Space 858-1,818 liters Maximum 2,158 liters
2023 Volkswagen iD.4 top and rear 3/4 view being driven on a road.